2024 SafeTREC Traffic Safety Facts: Preventing Roadside Deaths

Introduction

Preventing roadside deaths involving first responders (emergency medical service, law enforcement, and firefighting personnel), roadside assistance providers (vehicle towing personnel, mobile mechanics, emergency roadside technicians, and safety service patrollers), and those operating in work zones are of high priority for California. 

Move Over Laws & Work Zone Safety

Roadside crashes are preventable if drivers slow down, move over safely with regard to traffic conditions, and pay close attention to their environment.  California vehicle code (CVC) 20002, or the Steer Clear Law, requires that the driver involved in a crash where damage occurred to any property, including other vehicles, stop the vehicle immediately at the nearest location that will not impede the safety of other motorists or disrupt traffic. 

California also requires drivers to move, pull over, or take caution as to not create a hazard or impede traffic. California vehicle code (CVC) 21809, also known as the “Move Over” law, was enacted in 2007 and amended first in 2009 and then 2021.  It aims to create a safer environment for persons associated with certain authorized first responder and Caltrans vehicles stopped alongside roadways near traffic by requiring drivers to move over a lane, or if unable to do so safely to slow down, when approaching the stationary vehicle. The California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) seeks to increase awareness of highway safety laws such as California’s “Move Over” law with public education efforts including a safety campaign in partnership with the California Highway Patrol (CHP) and Office of Traffic Safety (OTS). 

Roadside Assistance Provider Fatalities

Roadside assistance providers (RAPs) help others when a crash occurs or if a vehicle breaks down.  They are particularly vulnerable to fatal or serious injury when struck by drivers traveling at high speeds.  

Roadside Assistance Provider (RAP) Fatalities in the US from 2015 - 2021

text detailing conditions when RAP fatalities occurred. For more information, please see the summary.

Data source: AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety. (2024). Roadside Assistance Providers Fatally Struck by Vehicles at the Roadside: Incidence and Characteristics, figure 7.

Summary 

  • In January 2024, the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety published a technical report analyzing the outcomes and characteristics of 123 RAP fatalities struck by drivers at the roadside in the United States from 2015 to 2021. 

  •  It found that 94.3% of RAP fatalities occurred outside of a vehicle on the shoulder, roadside, or in the travel lane, 88.6% of RAP fatalities were in locations with speed limits of 55 miles per hour or higher, and 62.6% of RAP fatalities occurred when lighting conditions were dark.   

  • Specialized training for RAPs, particularly to increase education around safety, such as avoiding working on the traffic-facing side of a scene, may help to prevent roadside fatalities.  Increased public compliance with “Move Over” laws may also help prevent crashes and fatalities occurring roadside.

Traffic Incident Management Training Programs

The California Traffic Incident Management (CA TIM) Training is provided through Caltrans to increase knowledge surrounding safely managing traffic incident scenes.  Upon training completion, participants are expected to apply pertinent codes to activities and tasks related to traffic incident management.  This training contains information specific to the State to supplement the Federal National Highway Institute (NHI) National Traffic Incident Management (TIM) Responder Training.  The NHI TIM Training covers topics like scene safety, safe vehicle positioning, command responsibilities, and traffic management, and must be completed prior to the CA TIM Training.  

Traffic Incident Management (TIM) Training Rates

pie chart detailing first responder TIM training rates.  For more information please see the summary.

Data source: National Operations Center of Excellence. (2024). TIM Responder Training, page 2. 

Summmary 

  • Despite training one of the highest number of responders in the nation in TIM at 30,464 individuals as of November 2023, only 36.2 percent of California’s responder workforce is NHI TIM trained, below the goal of 60 percent TIM trained.

TIM Training Rates across first Responder Groups in California*

bar chart detailing TIM training rates by first responder group. For more information, see the summary.

*Rates are as of November 2023

Data Source: National Operations Center of Excellence. (2024). TIM Responder Training, p5

Summary

  • All towing and recovery responders (100 percent) are trained in NHI TIM, while training rates for law enforcement, fire and rescue and EMS responders, and Caltrans or public works responder ranged from 10.7 percent to 69.2 percent.

Data Analysis

The figures in this section refer to fatalities that occurred in crashes involving a parked or working vehicle. 

Crashes involving Parked or Working Vehicles Fatality Trends

Chart detailing parked of working vehicle fatalities nationally and in California. For more information, please see the accompanying summary.

Data Source: FARS 2018 – 2021 Final File & 2022 ARF

Summary

  • Nationally, 1,234 individuals were killed in crashes involving a parked or working vehicles in 2022.
  • In California, 221 individuals were killed in crashes involving a parked or working vehicles in 2022.
  • Parked or working vehicles crash fatalities decreased nationally by 9.8 percent between 2021 and 2022.
  • Parked or working vehicles crash fatalities increased in California by 7.3 percent between 2021 and 2022.

California 

The following summary refers only to crashes involving a parked or working vehicle in California in 2022.

Top 5 Counties in California by Fatalities

RankingCountiesFatalities
1Los Angeles74
2San Bernardino21
3San Diego19
4Fresno15
5Riverside14

Data source: 2022 FARS ARF

Crash Location for Fatal Parked or Working Vehicle Crashes

Crash Location of Fatal Parked or Working Vehicle Crashes in California in 2022

infographic detailing the breakdown of fatal parked or working vehicle crashes by location in California in 2022. For more information, go to the following summary.

Data Sources: FARS 2022 ARF

Note: Urban and Rural areas are defined in the Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS) based on the boundaries decided by the US Census Bureau which considers population and housing density. 

Data source: i) Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS) ARF 2022; ii) California Public Road Data 2020. pp. 15-17, Table 4 2020 HPMS.

https://dot.ca.gov/-/media/dot-media/programs/research-innovation-system-information/documents/california-public-road-data/prd-2020-a11y.pdf

Summary 

  • The majority (89.3 percent) of parked or working vehicle fatal crashes occurred in urban areas, while 10. 7 percent occurred in rural areas.  For comparison, about 18.5 percent of travel took place on rural roads in 2020.
  • A little less than a quarter (21.9 percent) of fatal parked or working vehicle crashes occurred on Principal Arterials,  followed by Interstates and local roads (18.7 percent). 
  • Of all fatal parked or working vehicle crashes, 32.1 percent of crashes occurred on a roadway. This was followed by shoulder crashes which made up 25.1 percent and median and roadside crashes which made up 17.6 percent each. 

Top 5 Counties in California by Fatalities Per 100k Population

RankingCountyTraffic Stops per 100k Population
1Tehama4.6
2Lake3.0
3Fresno1.5
4Napa1.5
5Merced1.4

Note: Rankings are based on unrounded fatality rates. 

Data source: 2022 FARS ARF

 Fatal Parked or Working Vehicle Victim Demographics

Fatal Parked or Working Vehicle Victim Demographics

Infographic detailing the gender and race of fatalities in parked or working vehicle crash. For more information,  go to the following summary.

Data sources: 2022 FARS ARF

Summary 

  • The age category with the greatest number of parked or working vehicle crash fatalities was age 25-34, with 26.2 percent.  The next most common age category of parked or working vehicle crash fatalities was 15-24, with 21.3 percent of fatalities.  A majority (68.8 percent) of parked or working vehicle crash fatalities were male. 
  • For 66.5 percent of parked or working vehicle crash fatalities, race was unknown.  Of the victims with known race, 78.4 percent were white and 13.5 percent were Black or African American.